- OMB Completes its Review of the Final LDT Rule—A Final Rule Coming Anytime Now April 25, 2024
- Senators to DEA: Consider Treaty Obligations In Marijuana Rescheduling April 23, 2024
- “Heigh-ho” Taiho! The PTO Says LYTGOBI Patent is Ineligible for PTE Because of Untimely Application . . . And a Corrected NDA Approval Letter is No Saving Grace April 22, 2024
- Clear that Cabinet Tour ‘24 April 18, 2024
- The Fourth Circuit Upholds CMS’ Definition of “Line-Extension Drug” and “New Formulation” April 17, 2024
- Big Molecule Watch Blog
- Bloomberg BNA Health Care Blog
- Drug and Device Law Blog
- Eye on FDA
- FDA Matters
- Harvard Law Bill of Health
- IN VIVO Blog
- Internet Drug News.com
- Lachman Consultants Blog
- Medical Devices Today
- Orange Book Blog
- The Orange Book Insights Blog
- Pharma IQ
- Pharmalot
- SCOTUS Blog
- The Volokh Conspiracy
- WLF Legal Pulse
- Advertising and Promotion (Federal Trade Commission)
- Advertising and Promotion (OPDP)
- Animal Drugs and Feeds
- Biosimilars
- Cannabis
- cGMP Compliance
- Consumer Product Safety Commission
- Controlled Substances
- Cosmetics
- COVID19
- Current Affairs
- Dietary Supplements
- Drug Development
- Drug Enforcement Administration
- Enforcement
- FDA News
- Foods
- Foods and Dietary Supplements
- Fraud and Abuse
- Government Pricing
- Hatch-Waxman
- Health Care
- Health Privacy
- Import/Export
- In Vitro Diagnostic Devices
- Jobs
- Medical Devices
- Miscellaneous
- Orphan Drugs
- OTC Drugs and Cosmetics
- Prescription Drugs and Biologics
- Product Jurisdiction and Combination Products
- Reimbursement
- Tissue Products
- Tobacco
- Uncategorized
FDA Takes its Time to Brush Aside an APA Challenge
November 25, 2008In a November 10, 2008 response posted on November 24, 2008, FDA denied an April 27, 2005 Citizen Petition challenging a March 29, 2005 Interim Final Rule increasing Color Additive Certification Fees as violating the FDC Act and the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), because notice and comment rulemaking was required under the law.
FDA's response rejected the argument by the International Association of Color Manufacturers that notice and comment rulemaking was required, citing the APA's "contrary to public interest" exception to the general rule requiring notice and comment rulemaking.
While the question of whether FDA should proceed with an interim final rule, a direct final rule, a direct final rule in tandem with a proposed rule, or simply a proposed rule–in this case specifically or in connection with rulemakings generally–raises potentially interesting APA questions, one cannot help but feel that the writing was on the wall in connection with this issue as the increased fees have been in effect for over 3 and 1/2 years. Those who are intrigued by agency decisions concerning publication of rules may want to stay tuned to see how FDA proceeds in connection with its next Color Additive Certification Fee increase, which given the delay in responding to this Citizen Petition, may be just around the corner.
Search FDA Law Blog
Subscribe
Latest Tweets
Tweets by @fdalawblogAwards & Honors
- The Best
Lawyers in America
US News & World Report - Ranked in Chambers USA 2018
- OMB Completes its Review of the Final LDT Rule—A Final Rule Coming Anytime Now April 25, 2024
- Senators to DEA: Consider Treaty Obligations In Marijuana Rescheduling April 23, 2024
- “Heigh-ho” Taiho! The PTO Says LYTGOBI Patent is Ineligible for PTE Because of Untimely Application . . . And a Corrected NDA Approval Letter is No Saving Grace April 22, 2024
- Clear that Cabinet Tour ‘24 April 18, 2024
- The Fourth Circuit Upholds CMS’ Definition of “Line-Extension Drug” and “New Formulation” April 17, 2024
- Big Molecule Watch Blog
- Bloomberg BNA Health Care Blog
- Drug and Device Law Blog
- Eye on FDA
- FDA Matters
- Harvard Law Bill of Health
- IN VIVO Blog
- Internet Drug News.com
- Lachman Consultants Blog
- Medical Devices Today
- Orange Book Blog
- The Orange Book Insights Blog
- Pharma IQ
- Pharmalot
- SCOTUS Blog
- The Volokh Conspiracy
- WLF Legal Pulse
- Advertising and Promotion (Federal Trade Commission)
- Advertising and Promotion (OPDP)
- Animal Drugs and Feeds
- Biosimilars
- Cannabis
- cGMP Compliance
- Consumer Product Safety Commission
- Controlled Substances
- Cosmetics
- COVID19
- Current Affairs
- Dietary Supplements
- Drug Development
- Drug Enforcement Administration
- Enforcement
- FDA News
- Foods
- Foods and Dietary Supplements
- Fraud and Abuse
- Government Pricing
- Hatch-Waxman
- Health Care
- Health Privacy
- Import/Export
- In Vitro Diagnostic Devices
- Jobs
- Medical Devices
- Miscellaneous
- Orphan Drugs
- OTC Drugs and Cosmetics
- Prescription Drugs and Biologics
- Product Jurisdiction and Combination Products
- Reimbursement
- Tissue Products
- Tobacco
- Uncategorized